Jonathan Keigher, PhD | Relational Psychotherapy for Anxious ATTACHMENT

Anxious Attachment Treatment in New York

When closeness matters deeply, uncertainty in a relationship can be hard to tolerate.

Understand the patterns beneath relationship anxiety and develop a more secure way of connecting.

You care deeply about your relationships. Maybe sometimes too deeply. A delayed text feels different than it probably should. A change in someone's tone catches your attention immediately. A little distance leaves you wondering whether something is wrong. You replay conversations. You look for reassurance. u notice subtle changes in the other person's behavior and try to figure out what they mean.


When the relationship feels secure, you can relax. When it doesn't, everything else becomes harder to focus on. Part of you may recognize that your reaction is bigger than the situation. But knowing that doesn't necessarily make the feeling disappear.


This is one of the difficult things about anxious attachment: Your mind may know the relationship is probably okay while another part of you is already preparing to lose it.

You're not really waiting for a text anymore. You're waiting to know that the relationship is okay.


How does this develop?

There isn't one anxious-attachment childhood. People arrive at these patterns in different ways. For some, important early relationships were inconsistent: warm at times and emotionally unavailable at others. For others, the important experiences came later: rejection, betrayal, abandonment, a painful breakup.


What matters is what you gradually learned about closeness. If connection felt uncertain, it made sense to pay attention to it. You learned to notice changes in tone, to read people's moods, to recognize distance quickly, to repair things before they got worse.


You became good at watching relationships.

Woman anxiously checking her phone

The problem is that it's very difficult to relax in a relationship you're always watching.

Sometimes you become so focused on the other person that you lose track of yourself.

When you're worried about losing someone, your attention naturally moves toward them. What are they thinking? What are they feeling? Are they upset? Those questions can become so consuming that another set of questions disappears:  What am I feeling? What do I want? Am I getting what I need?


You may find yourself accommodating more than you want to, avoiding disagreements, apologizing quickly, explaining yourself too much. At some point,  maintaining the relationship can become more important than asking whether the relationship is working for you.

When you're worried about losing someone, your attention naturally moves toward them. What are they thinking? What are they feeling? Are they upset? Those questions can become so consuming that another set of questions disappears:  What am I feeling? What do I want? Am I getting what I need?


You may find yourself accommodating more than you want to, avoiding disagreements, apologizing quickly, explaining yourself too much. At some point,  maintaining the relationship can become more important than asking whether the relationship is working for you.

Reassurance helps. Until you need it again.

People sometimes feel embarrassed about needing reassurance. I don't think that's particularly useful. Everyone needs reassurance sometimes. The issue is what happens when reassurance doesn't last: your partner tells you everything is fine, you feel better, then their mood changes, and you're back where you started.



This happens because reassurance can settle the immediate anxiety without changing the expectation underneath it. Therapy isn't about convincing you that you shouldn't need reassurance. We're trying to build something more durable underneath it.

Sometimes the things we do to get closer accidentally create more distance.

You sense distance and want to restore connection, so you reach out. If the other person doesn't respond the way you hoped, you reach a little harder. Sometimes anger enters the picture. You may say, "Fine, I don't care," when you care very much.


But the other person may experience your reaching as pressure and pull away. Now there's more distance. You become more anxious. They feel more pressured. And before long, both people are caught in a cycle neither of them intended to create.

Couple in a tense conversation, one leaning in and one pulling away

This is where anxious and avoidant patterns often collide.

When one person feels insecure, they move closer. When the other person feels overwhelmed, they move away. The first person experiences that distance as threatening and pursues more. The second person experiences the pursuit as pressure and needs even more space.

Neither person is necessarily trying to hurt the other. They're both trying to regulate themselves. They're just doing it in opposite directions. Usually, I'm much more interested in understanding the cycle itself than in who started it.

Not everything is your attachment style.

Sometimes people become so familiar with attachment language that they start explaining everything through it. But sometimes you're anxious because the person you're dating is actually inconsistent. Sometimes someone really is emotionally unavailable. Sometimes your relationship doesn't feel secure because it isn't secure.


Therapy shouldn't teach you to distrust your own perceptions. We need to sort out what belongs to the past and what belongs to the relationship you're actually in.

What might anxious attachment look like?

You might recognize yourself in some of these experiences. You don't need to relate to all of them.

  • Overthinking texts or conversations
  • Worrying that someone is losing interest
  • Becoming very distressed when someone feels distant
  • Frequently needing reassurance that things are okay
  • Replaying interactions to figure out what someone meant
  • Feeling responsible for another person's mood
  • Having difficulty tolerating uncertainty in relationships
  • Becoming jealous or preoccupied with possible rejection
  • Avoiding conflict for fear of what it could do to the relationship
  • Having trouble maintaining boundaries when you're afraid of losing someone
  • Feeling secure together but much less secure when apart
  • Becoming involved repeatedly with people who are difficult to reach emotionally
  • Knowing you're overthinking and still being unable to stop

What do we actually do in therapy?

We try to understand what happens to you when attachment anxiety gets activated, not just afterward but in the moment. What did you notice? What did you immediately assume? What did you feel? What did you want to do next?



We slow that sequence down and find more room to work with it: learning to tolerate uncertainty without immediately trying to resolve it, communicating needs more directly, setting boundaries, and figuring out when your anxiety is telling an old story versus giving you useful information about the relationship you're actually in.

Eventually, your relationship with me may become part of the conversation too.

You don't leave your attachment system outside the therapy room. At some point, you may wonder what I think of you, or worry that you've disappointed me. We don't have to treat those moments as problems. We can talk about them.


You can disagree with someone without losing the relationship. You can have needs without apologizing for having them. You can experience a rupture and repair it. That's different from simply learning about secure attachment. You're getting to experience some of it.

Attachment isn't only intellectual. You can't necessarily reason yourself out of something that was learned emotionally and reinforced through relationships.

What does becoming more secure actually look like?

It doesn't mean becoming detached. It doesn't mean you stop caring. And it definitely doesn't mean never needing anyone. You may still want reassurance. You may still feel hurt when someone pulls away. The difference is that the feeling doesn't take over immediately. There's more room around it.


You can ask someone what's happening instead of trying to figure it out alone. You can tolerate not knowing for a while. You can care deeply about whether someone chooses you while also asking whether you're choosing them.

Not needing people less. Feeling safer being yourself while you're close to them.

Ready to Take the Next Step?

You don't have to stop caring deeply about relationships.


Therapy can help you understand why uncertainty feels so powerful, recognize the patterns that shape how you connect with others, and develop a more secure relationship with both yourself and the people who matter to you.


If relationships often leave you feeling anxious, preoccupied, or uncertain, therapy can help you explore what’s happening in those moments and why they hold so much emotional weight. The goal is to build enough security so that closeness becomes something you can simply enjoy, rather than something you feel you must constantly watch over and protect.